Managing
stormwater runoff with detention ponds is like trying to lose
weight by taking diet pills: long-term consequences outweigh
short-term benefits. Natural systems such as wetlands do the
job better, more beautifully, and more responsibly.
By Deborah Snoonian, P.E.
Think of a summer storm as a form of theater. Lightning shrieks
across the sky, thunder reverberates in your chest, raindrops
splash onto their earthly targetsa spectacle of heavenly
sight and sound whose final act is played out underfoot. Next
time youre caught in a thunderstorm, look down at it,
not upwhat youll see is runoff. Environmentally
speaking, its a real problem.
The main culprit is progress: The concrete jungles
of increasing urbanization interfere with the normal water
cycle. When rainwater falls in forests or on vegetated lands,
some of it is used by plants, some percolates through the
soil and replenishes aquifers, and some of it evaporates;
consequently, theres little or no surface flow over
these natural areas. In contrast, a whopping 70 to 90 percent
of rainwater that falls on impervious surfaces ends up as
runoff.
 |
|
|
|
Wetlands are attractive. as well as
functional, site elements.
|
 |
As rainwater streams down city streets, it picks up sediment,
oils, greases, metals, and airborne particulates. This cocktail
of pollutants often flows untreated into natural bodies of
water, and numerous studies show its a major cause of
impaired water quality and harm to aquatic plants and wildlife.
According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), almost
half of the nations waterways are compromised by polluted
runoff. Even when there is a treatment program, large surges
of runoff entering sewage treatment plants during storms stress
these systems to their capacity.
But just as nature punishes, so it can accommodate. Intentionally
constructed wetlands, implemented as part of site planning
or landscaping, reduce the amount of runoff leaving a site
while also cleansing it of harmful substances.
Granted, architects dont design landscapes. Or wetlands.
But they do design the buildings and cities that create runoff,
meaning that their decisions have implications beyond the
projects in their immediate control. Just as environmental
laws are turning up the heat on clients to safeguard natural
resources, theyre also compelling architects to learn
strategies such as natural stormwater management to mitigate
the overall environmental effects of their work.
Green machines
Flood control has long been the bailiwick of civil engineers,
who study a building site and then design storm sewers and
detention ponds to drain it. These strategies prevent short-term
flooding, but theyve contributed to the problems we
face today. And engineered solutions for stormwater management
tend to be, shall we say, clunky. An eyesore is
what one architect termed them.
Constructed wetlands, on the other hand, are an organic
form of infrastructure: They work with and by the laws of
nature, not against them. Generally, wetlandsboth natural
and man-madeare areas that are filled or saturated with
water for all or part of the year. These soggy conditions
promote the development of hydric soils, which are characteristic
of saturated areas, along with the growth of specially adapted
plant species. A bog is a wetland. So are marshes, swamps,
and creeks.
|
Case Study
Herman Miller furniture plant,
Cherokee County, Ga.
Firm: Michael
Van Valkenburgh Associates, Inc., New York
Working with Mack Scogin Merrill Elam Architects, vanguard
landscape architecture firm Michael Van Valkenburgh
Associates designed the site for a new factory for the
leading furniture mavens, located in pristine, hilly
farm country north of Atlanta. The program called for
an immense flat-roofed factory building, 550 parking
spots, and a paved area for staging hundreds of storage
trailers. The project team wanted to reduce the volume
of runoff leaving the site. Typically, you take
care of the building program requirements, then shunt
stormwater in pipes to a retention basin, said
Matthew Urbanski, a firm principal. Instead, we
used storm- water management to inform the landscape
design, break up the parking areas structurally, and
make an experience of going into the factory.
Rather than creating a single large parking lot, Urbanski
designed a mosaic of smaller, triangular lots without
curbs, which are interspersed with flat terraces planted
with wetland vegetation in which water will pool during
storms before percolating slowly through the soil. Theyre
sort of like rice paddies, he observes. One concern
was that mosquitoes would breed in the standing water,
but the terraces are designed to retain water for no
more than seven daysless than the incubation time
for a mosquito egg.
Tight rows of small trees of varying species were
planted along the terrace edges. Over time, the trees
will grow and distinguish the parking areas as site
features. Urbanski calls the scheme a conflation
of infrastructure, landscape, and program. The
landscape has a repetitive quality to ita fitting
solution for a factory.
Also on the boards is the Athletic Center at the University
of Iowa, in conjunction with this years aia-award-winning
firm Herbert Lewis Kruse Blunck Architecture. The project
will involve regrading a 50-acre site, with sculptural
forms and grading around a new soccer field dictated
by runoff management. Infiltration strips and wetlands
will manage parking lot drainage.
|
Wetlands serve several important ecological functions: Their
plants and aquatic life cleanse surface and groundwater; they
reduce flooding by acting as natural sponges, storing stormwater
and slowly releasing it back to natural waterways; they prevent
erosion by stabilizing soil; and they serve as a critical
feeding ground and habitat for fish, waterfowl, and other
wildlife. As stormwater runoff enters a wetland system, its
velocity decreases, which allows sediments and solids to settle
out. Plants break down and synthesize organic pollutants,
such as oils and greases, and also use metals and minerals
in urban runoff as nutrients for growth.
The environmental benefits of wetlands extend beyond the
mere site level. Ponds and plant life diminish the urban
heat island effect, in which impervious surfaces, such
as rooftops and parking lots, radiate sunlight back into the
atmosphere, increasing the temperature over these regionsa
phenomenon that contributes to global climate change.
|